wenn vs. wann. Two words, one English word.
English "when" does two completely different jobs: it asks a question, and it links two statements. German never lets one word do both. wann asks. wenn links. Mixing them up is one of the most common mistakes English-speaking learners make, often without noticing.
One English word, two German words
Look at these two English sentences. Both use "when." In German, they need two completely different words.
| English | German | Why |
|---|---|---|
| When does the course start? | Wann beginnt derKurs? | It's a question. |
| When the course starts, I'll be there. | Wenn derKurs beginnt, bin ich da. | It links two clauses. |
| When are you free? | Wann hast du Zeit? | It's a question. |
| When you have time, call me. | Wenn du Zeithast, ruf mich an. | It links two clauses. |
wann wants an answer: a time, a date, a clock reading. wenn wants nothing. It just connects a condition or a moment to a result.
The trap: indirect questions
The mistake almost never happens with sentences that end in a question mark. It happens with sentences that look like statements but secretly contain a question.
"I don't know when he's coming."
→ "Ich weiß nicht, wann er kommt." Not wenn.
This sentence has no question mark, so it's tempting to reach for wenn. But pull the clause out on its own: "When is he coming?" That's a question. And every hidden question about time belongs to wann, no matter how deep inside the sentence it sits.
| English (looks like a statement) | Hidden question | German |
|---|---|---|
| I don't know when the train leaves. | When does the train leave? | Ich weiß nicht, wann derZug abfährt. |
| Can you tell me when the shop opens? | When does the shop open? | Kannst du mir sagen, wann derLaden öffnet? |
| She asked when we have time. | When do you have time? | Sie hat gefragt, wann wir Zeithaben. |
The quick test
Try replacing "when" with "at what time?" If that still makes sense, even as a question buried inside the sentence, use wann. If "when" really means "if," "whenever," or "at the moment that," use wenn.
| Sentence with "when" | Replace with "at what time?" | Replace with "if / whenever" | Use |
|---|---|---|---|
| I don't know when she arrives. | ✓ I don't know at what time she arrives. | ✗ | wann |
| When she arrives, call me. | ✗ | ✓ Whenever she arrives, call me. | wenn |
| Tell me when the meeting is. | ✓ Tell me at what time the meeting is. | ✗ | wann |
| When it rains, I stay home. | ✗ | ✓ If/whenever it rains, I stay home. | wenn |
Both send the verb to the end, so the order doesn't help
Here's why the confusion is so persistent: both wann and wenn send the verb to the end of their clause when they're not the very first word in the sentence. Word order can't tell them apart, only meaning can.
| Clause | Verb | Word | Meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| ...wann derKurs | beginnt | wann | asks "when does it begin?" |
| ...wenn derKurs | beginnt | wenn | states "when/if it begins" |
Same word order, same verb position, opposite jobs. The only way through is the question test above.
Can you turn it into a question, "...at what time...?", even hidden inside another sentence? wann.
Is it a condition or a recurring moment, "if" or "whenever"? wenn.
More on each word individually: wann. Asking for a point in time. and wenn. When or if, the verb goes last. For a single moment in the past, neither applies, that's als. One moment in the past.